Slavery and Spiritual Dignity: A Buddhist Response to the Vatican’s Vesak Message
[ point evaluation5/5 ]1 people who voted
On 21 April, the Roman Catholic Church issued a Vesak message for the world’s Buddhists, titled “Buddhists and Christians, together to counter modern slavery.” The president of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue, Cardinal Jean-Louis Tauran, reached out to Buddhists by stating: “ . . . the Buddha declares that trading in live beings, including slaves and prostitutes, is one of five occupations that are not to be engaged in. He instructs that possessions are to be acquired peacefully, honestly and by legal means, without coercion, violence or deceit, and by means that do not cause harm or suffering. In this way, Buddhism promotes respect for the life and freedom of each person.”
This message had its antecedents in a meeting on 2 December 2014 at the Vatican, where representatives of different faiths met Pope Francis to co-sign the Declaration of Religious Leaders against Slavery.* The Buddhist signatories were Venerable Thich Nhy Chan Khong, who represented Zen master Thich Nhat Hanh (as she has so often done so throughout her exemplary life), and The Most Venerable Datuk K. Sri Dhammaratana, chief high priest of Malaysia’s Buddhists. CardinalTauran’s Vesak appeal therefore wielded considerable moral weight because it maintained thematic continuity with an issue already on the agenda between Buddhist and Catholic leaders before Vesak.
Ven. Chan Khong at the signing of the Declaration of Religious Leaders against Slavery on 2 December 2014. From amritapuri.org
Slavery is a global blight, and the December co-signatories, in the language of the Declaration, vowed to “wipe out all forms of” it by 2020. This is a bold commitment that Buddhists are not all beholden to, since Buddhism has no centralized authority like the Pope. Nevertheless, by co-signing, Ven. Chan Khong and The Most Venerable Dhammaratana have challenged the world’s Buddhists to follow their example.
In its contemporary incarnation, the numbers involved in the slave trade surpass any other time in history. The Pope gave some examples in his XLVIII Message for the World Day of Peace on 1 January: men and women in indentured servitude and child workers; migrants who endure physical, emotional, and sexual abuse while working in appalling conditions; anyone forced into prostitution; male and female sex slaves; and people forced to fight in wars. The UN estimates the total number of men, women, and children in slavery (counting all of Pope Francis’s examples, including trafficked people) to be a staggering 27 to 30 million, with an annual turnover of US$35 billion.
The Vatican’s invitation deserves a serious and sympathetic response from Buddhists. Almost all religions agree that slavery violates every definition of human dignity. Slavery is insidious enough in a secular context, but the implications become even viler when it is recast in a Buddhist worldview, in which the human being is actually a Buddha.
Many forms of slavery, including forced labor and the sex slave trade, are rife in regions where Buddhism has a presence—Southeast Asia, South Asia, and parts of East Asia. Women and children from impoverished families are abused and trafficked around the world for sexual exploitation, which encompasses 58 per cent of the total slave trade. In Nepal, where Hinduism and Buddhism intertwine in daily life, the UN estimates that 12–15,000 girls are smuggled out of the country annually, ending up in brothels in India or as far away as South Korea. That number, reports The Guardian, is set to spike with the tragic earthquake in April that devastated so many towns, villages, and families.
At the patrician villa of Casina Pio IV in the Vatican, The Most Venerable Dhammaratana gave an excellent address about slavery, highlighting its universal nature: “The truth of life is everything changes, we grow with time and embrace the changes. . . . However, the truth hurts—the advancement that we grow with sadly did not reflect in humanity [sic]. We are still witnessing all the barbaric and horrifying acts of humans [sic] which should have been abandoned a long time ago. Humans have certainly advanced in technology but not spiritually.” His message was particularly poignant because Malaysia has an unenviable reputation for serious human trafficking violations and an effective tolerance of slavery, with labor rights organization Verité reporting forced work to be especially endemic in the electronics industry.
The Most Venerable Dhammaratana signs the Declaration of Religious Leaders against Slavery on 2 December 2014. From globalfreedomnetwork.org
Religious and secular institutions alike should commit to identifying the root causes forcing people into lives of physical, emotional, and spiritual degradation. Modern slavery is a by-product of interlocking conditions, the main cause of which is poverty. When educational and economic opportunities that provide routes out of that poverty are absent or unattainable, families and individuals turn to destructive alternatives through a mix of desperation and ignorance (itself a result of a lack of education). In many cases of forced labor or sex slavery, innocent people are duped into nonexistent promises of economic opportunity and subjected to illegal means of physical, social, and financial control after being trapped. Finally, weak political, legal, and ecclesiastic institutions cannot or are unwilling to challenge slavery as a “fact of life” for society’s forsaken.
How people end up inside the grinding machine of slavery is a collective, global problem and cannot be blamed on individuals. Instead, governments, businesses, and charities need to collaborate in providing economic and educational opportunities that allow people to move out of poverty whilst strengthening the institutions (such as the law, social services, and organized religion) that provide moral and practical bulwarks against the shame of slavery. It is also important to practice forgiveness for the perpetrators while applying restorative justice so that they can atone for their crimes.
On an indirect level, private citizens can refuse to buy products made through forced and child labor, and shame companies exploiting forced laborers and children through campaigns and petitions, particularly on social media. Pressure from the market and public relations can incentivize companies to reform any practices that contribute to the exploitation or indirect abuse of people.
The defeat of slavery (if, as we hope, it is possible) will be long and difficult, taking at least several generations. However, the Catholic Church’s Vesak message deserves an enthusiastic affirmation and endorsement from the Buddhist community. Our sangha is not powerful enough to defeat slavery on its own. But by working together with the world’s religions, alongside the global faithful, we can help to accelerate its end.
*Prior to this Declaration, Global Freedom Network was inaugurated on 17 March 2014 under the auspices of Walk Free Foundation and several co-signatories of the Declaration of Religious Leaders against Slavery (the Buddhist co-signatories were not present at the March 2014 event). It included a commitment to eradicate modern slavery and human trafficking by 2020.
Source: newlotus.buddhistdoor (May 15, 2015)